Odd this day

Coates
4 min readJan 31, 2023

--

31 January, so… the anniversary of the demise of Guy Fawkes? Bit obvious, maybe. How about Ham the Astrochimp going into space?

No, because, in 1996, this was the opening night of The Fields of Ambrosia, a West End musical about… a travelling executioner.

Front cover, soundtrack album of The Fields of Ambrosia, depicting a man sweeping his hat off his head to reveal an idyllic rural scene with rainbow

Yes, Jonas Candide drives around the Deep South in a colourful van with a portable electric chair in the back, visits penitentiaries, and despatches wrong ’uns. And sings to them, comfortingly, about where they’re off to: “the fields of ambrosia, where everyone knows ya”.

No, really.

You may not be surprised to hear that it closed after 23 performances, but its Wikipedia entry may cause you to ask why, if the New York Times called it a “new kind of musical” with

the essence of black comedy … violence, sex, romance and sentiment

Well, let’s look at what the NYT actually said when it reviewed the first production in New Jersey a couple of years earlier, shall we…?

NEW BRUNSWICK — A RECIPE for the new kind of musical that “The Fields of Ambrosia” means to be: take the essence of black comedy, smatter it with the stock ingredients of violence, sex, romance and sentiment, and — this is crucial — make sure the concoction is through composed, without dialogue, so that it can pass for art. If the result comes out half baked, or quasi-artistic, that’s because pretension got in the way of aspiration, and imitation was mistaken for innovation.

Back to London, and Benedict Nightingale in the Times opened with:

This American musical isn’t quite another ‘Springtime for Hitler’, though there were moments in the first scene when I thought it might be

The ‘story’ — if that isn’t too dignified a word for what was laid out before the paying punters — is that Jonas has happily despatched scores of men, and is suddenly asked to off a woman called Gretchen. WHAT COULD POSSIBLY GO WRONG?

CD cover: Original Cast Recording, The Fields of Ambrosia, with a photo of Joel Higgins and his bowler hat again, and Christine Andreas, the female lead

Well, wouldn’t you know it? It turns out she’s beautiful, and — even if her last sugar daddy did come to an unfortunate end — not really a bad person AT ALL. Or as one of the prison warders puts it, “I figure your ass is too good to fry”.

Yes, it was a startling, taste-free, unhinged, tone-deaf mess. And I know this because I saw it. I love bad art.

A digression

My commitment to trash is such that I even saw Leonardo The Musical, which had been financed by the Republic of Nauru’s guano deposits, and centred around a famous painter, not noted in life for his heterosexuality, doinking a married woman called Lisa whose portrait he is working on.

Publicity image from Leonardo The Musical, subtitle A Portrait of Love, with a brushstroke design, within which we see the Mona Lisa, and a ghostly face, presumably that of Leonardo

That was spectaular. Also, someone who had recently become an ex-friend was in Fields of Ambrosia, so…

Lloyd Bridges in Airplane, superimposed with the words “Looks like I picked the wrong week to give up schadenfreude”

Anyway…

This show was gloriously stupid. Or, as the Independent review put it, it:

left this critic weak with bliss as it trampled over good taste and political correctness like a herd of bullocks.

It might have worked, as Nightingale pointed out:

It could, I guess, be argued that Sondheim took risks with taste in Sweeney Todd; but he was wittily reworking a 19th-century melodrama and, in the process, saying something serious about evil begetting evil. Call it good taste, call it the right tone, call it a basic moral sense: there is something missing in Joel Higgins and Martin Silvestri’s tale

But don’t take his word for it; take mine. When one inmate, Jimmy, is dragged into the back of the van and raped by two other prisoners, he emerges to sing the words

If it ain’t one thing it’s another

No, really.

It wasn’t all jaw-droppingly horrific, though. It was also extremely funny. Unintentionally. At the climax of the first act, for example, the man who’s about to get done in shouts to the executioner:

Do it, boy! Fry me while I’m hot!

Sadly, not much remains of it. If you look very hard, you might track down the original cast recording, and you can hear the title track on YouTube:

You can even — as I discovered to my considerable and pleasant surprise when I started reading up on this — see the trailer for the 1970 Stacy Keach film The Traveling Executioner on which it’s based, which I had not previously heard of, and which I now very much want to watch in full:

…or we can all just enjoy some more quotes from the reviews of the musical:

Morally unappealing … disgusting and titillating (Standard)

All very strange … As if everyone has had any sense of good taste, or indeed morality, surgically removed (Telegraph)

But perhaps the last word should go to Benedict Nightingale:

Oddly, there is genuine talent on display. Silvestri can turn a breezy country tune. Higgins the librettist may have his limitations, but Higgins the actor has lots of laid-back assurance, and Andreas has a fine, pure voice. Yet if it is easy to see why both principals have strong Broadway credits, it is hard to understand why they are over here. What next a hanging, gassing, shooting or lethal-injection show? A new genre beckons: the Terminal Follies.

…or, no: maybe his Independent counterpart, Paul Taylor:

Often very funny in its own right, the show has a number of moments where it seems to be tone deaf to its own ridiculousness. To sing about letting sleeping dogs lie when you have a comatose rat on your operating table, as Michael Fenton Stevens’s whisky doctor does, is to throw the cat among the pigeons, sense-wise. With high-voltage performances all round, though, and a strong so-bad-it’s-good factor, this show makes a pretty sunny vacation from seriousness and propriety.

But maybe we should turn to that ‘whisky doctor’, Mike Fenton Stevens. When I posted about this on Twitter, he expressed his sympathy for the show’s producers:

The opening night was like the opening night of Springtime For Hitler. But without the ticket sales.

And, finally, if you’d prefer to put all this behind you, you can still find out about Ham the Astrochimp

Chimpanzee “Ham” in space suit is fitted into the couch of the Mercury-Redstone 2 capsule #5 prior to its test flight which was conducted on January 31, 1961

I’m not judging. Each to their own, I say.

--

--

Coates
Coates

Written by Coates

Purveyor of niche drivel; marker of odd anniversaries

No responses yet