Odd this day

Coates
3 min readDec 17, 2023

--

So, happy 125th anniversary of the day 78-year-old Faroppo Lorenzo was buried alive for science.

Artist’s impression of Le Karnice, a device to alert people on the surface when a person had been buried alive. Image shows a body in a coffin, with a pipe leading to an apparatus linked to a flag. If buried, the pipe would lead to the surface, alerting passers by — and bring oxygen down to the coffin. Illustration from Wellcome Image Library, from W. Tebb’s 1905 book, Premature Burial and how it may be prevented.

The aim was to demonstrate Le Karnice, a ‘security coffin’ created by Russian nobleman Count Michel de Karnice-Karnicki – who wasn’t only responding to a fashionable obsession with premature burial. He’d once witnessed something nasty.

The count’s carefree life was changed, however, by a horrific experience while he was attending the funeral of a young Belgian girl. When the first shovels of earth were thrown upon her coffin, she awoke from her death and her piteous screams haunted him ever since. He decided to invent a mechanical apparatus to save the lives of those prematurely, buried. His first invention was a coffin with a large glass pane in the lid…

That’s an excerpt from Jan Bondeson’s Buried Alive, which is indeed an entire book about “our most primal fear”.

Front cover: Buried Alive: The Terrifying History of Our Most Primal Fear by Jan Bondeson. Image shows a horrified person reaching out of a coffin with one arm as they lift the lid with the other

Apparently, Karnice-Karnicki first came up with a coffin with a large window in the lid which could be broken — but this was only useful if you were buried in a vault, and the Count wanted his invention to be available to poor people, too, so he eventually came up with the 3.5in diameter pipe “emerging above ground rather like the periscope of a submarine”.

Photo of Le Karnice, a device to alert people on the surface when a person had been buried alive. Image shows a model corpse in a coffin, with a pipe leading to an apparatus linked to a flag. If buried, the pipe would lead to the surface, alerting passers by — and bring oxygen down to the coffin

Apparently, George Washington’s last wish was that he be

decently buried; and do not let my body be put into the vault in less than three days after I am dead

and 100 years later, people were still worried about this.

Mind you, in December 1899, the Chicago Tribune reported on a meeting of the Academy of Medicine in New York, where a Dr. Henry J. Garrigues said one in every 200 people buried in the US was actually “in a lethargic state”, which can’t have helped.

Press cutting: MANY DEATHS IN GRAVE, STARTLING STATEMENT OF THE EXTENT OF PREMATURE BURIAL. New York Physician Declares That One of Every Two Hundred People Put Under the Ground Is Really Alive — Urges That Existing Methods Should Be Reformed — Russian’s Device for a Cemetery Alarm System — General News of a Gotham Day.

This was what an actual scientist would call an unevidenced assertion. The Count, however, was not a charlatan, and had put some thought into his invention. The box on top was particularly clever. Karnice-Karnicki had visited mortuaries, so he knew dead people… exuded an aroma, and the box stopped gases escaping. If you should find yourself underground and not dead, though, it would let air in.

Illustration from patent application for Le Karnice, showing internal workings of “apparatus for saving people buried alive”. Technical drawing shows levers and valves for allowing oxygen in if the person is alive, but keeping the stench in if they’re dead

Le Karnice impressed people as varied as “influential Parisian … Professor Charles Richet, … the prefect of Milan, and the inspector of cemeteries”, but it didn’t catch on. Mind you, the Count didn’t really help himself.

To argue his case further, he wrote a pamphlet entitled Vie ou mort. The count’s prose was rather bombastic and florid: for example, he wrote that premature burial was such a torture that it made all the torments that the Romans inflicted on the Christians at the Circus in Rome seem mild by comparison. He deplored the flippant journalists who had made fun of him, and blasted the conniving funeral directors who had promised to order coffins but failed to make good their promises

The biggest problem, though was that the mechanism was too sensitive. The bell, telling you someone was alive, could be triggered by the slightest movement — and the slightest movement might be down to… well, putrefaction.

A decomposing Griffin Dunne in American Werewolf in London

Faroppo stayed buried for nine days, which means three things:

  1. he emerged on Christmas Day
  2. this septuagenarian was made of stern stuff (his only comment was that it had been “damned smelly down there”), and
  3. he still holds the Guinness World Record for longest voluntary burial. Which suggests to me that all those people going for ‘most toothpicks in a beard’ and ‘fastest chug of two litres of soda’ are bloody cowards.

(Also, I’m afraid I don’t know whether Karnice-Karnicki ever gave anyone a hickey, but I like to think so.)

--

--

Coates
Coates

Written by Coates

Purveyor of niche drivel; marker of odd anniversaries

Responses (1)