Odd this day

Coates
4 min readJul 2, 2023

--

Ah! 2 July, 71st anniversary of the day Mary Reeser’s landlady went to deliver a telegram and found her door handle too hot to touch. She called the police, and the photo of what they found launched a million childhood nightmares.

Photo of what was left of Reeser’s body, made famous by Unexplained magazine in the 1970s. it shows a toilet in the background, the burned remains of what looks like a zimmer frame/mobility aid, charred carpet/lino, and the bottom section of a human leg, still wearing a shoe or slipper

It was made most famous by that stalwart of 1970s coffee tables, The Unexplained magazine:

…and even popped up on the BBC’s QED (in an episode which sounds like it’s being voiced over by BAFTA-winning — but not for this — Anna Massey):

Was it spontaneous human combustion? Was that really a thing? Might it happen to me IN MY BED AT NIGHT? Probably not, although what happened is apparently still a mystery. Still, some explanations are more plausible than others…

All sorts of theories were sent in to the local police chief, including the magnificent

A ball of fire came through the open window and hit her. I seen it happen

Thankfully, the days of scientifically illiterate people saying any old bollocks in response to a news story are all behind us now

Aaron Bastani tweet following Beirut explosion August 2020. It shows an image of the cloud generated by the explosion, with his comment: “This looks like it could be a thermobaric weapon in Beirut. Appalling.”

Eventually, the police in this case wrote to yer actual J Edgar Hoover and asked the FBI to look into it.

Press cutting — St Petersburg Times, Thursday July 5 1951: Police get plenty of advice, but no new clues in Reeser Death; Debris sent to Lab. by Jerry Blizin. Detectives yesterday finished packing the last of several boxes of material salvaged from an apartment at 1200 Cherry Street Northeast, where Mrs Mary Hardy Reeser, 67, was burned to death in a mystery fire Monday. The boxes will be sent off today to the FBI laboratory in Washington for chemical analysis

The FBI’s explanation — “that Mrs. Reeser’s own body fat provided the fuel for the fire that consumed her” — is still considered the most likely, but that doesn’t mean it was spontaneous:

Mrs. Reeser was visited shortly before her death by her physician son, Richard Reeser. She was depressed because she thought she wasn’t going to be able to travel north for the summer. She hadn’t eaten dinner and told her son she had taken two Seconal tablets and might take two more before retiring. According to the FBI, the sedated widow apparently sat down in an upholstered chair and fell asleep while smoking a cigarette. The cigarette set fire to her acetate nightgown and housecoat. Though the upholstered chair had fire-retardant treatment, it burned, too. At the end of the fire Mrs. Reeser was gone, and nothing remained of the chair but the springs.

Mary wasn’t the first. The first documented case was in 1635, with Countess Cornelia Bandi providing one of the most historically celebrated instances in 1741. She, too, left her legs behind:

Extract from Philosphical Transactions giving some Account of the present undertakings, studies and labours of the Ingenious in many considerable parts of the world, Vol XLIII for the years 1744 and 1745Four Feet Distance from the Bed there was a Heap of Ashes, two Legs untouched, from the Foot to the Knee, with their Stockings on; between them was the Lady’s head; whose Brains, Half of the Backpart of the Scull, and the whole Chin, were burnt to Ashes

(Whatever started the fire in her case probably wasn’t helped by her habit of regularly chucking camphorated brandy over herself as some sort of health remedy.)

Mary also wasn’t the last. Mysterious consumings by fire were still being reported in the early 1990s “but after that it sort of trailed off”. Why? Well, it might be that people don’t smoke late at night in highly flammable clothes any more.

…or (my theory) people are still dying this way in the same numbers, but journalists now are on average younger than those of us traumatised by that photo, so they don’t cover the subject to quite the same extent that previous generations did.

Anyway, to distract from all this unpleasantness, let’s look at a lovely children’s book. Oh dear, it’s Struwwelpeter, in which Harriet plays with matches, and leaves behind only her shoes…

Extract from Struwwelpeter, 1845 German children’s book by Heinrich Hoffmann, chapter 3, Die gar traurige Geschichte mit dem Feuerzeug (The Very Sad Tale with the Matches) in which a girl plays with matches, accidentally ignites herself and burns to death: “So she was burnt, with all her clothes / And arms, and hands, and eyes, and nose; / Till she had nothing more to lose / Except her little scarlet shoes; / And nothing else but these was found / Among her ashes on the ground
Illustration from Struwwelpeter shows Harriet with her green dress on fire, flanked by two cats, their forepaws aloft in horror. Below this is another illustration, of the two cats crying over a pile of ash — and Harriet’s red shoes

Please don’t have nightmares. Do sleep well.

Nick Ross in his BBC Crimewatch days

--

--

Coates
Coates

Written by Coates

Purveyor of niche drivel; marker of odd anniversaries

No responses yet